What an online store really costs over 5 years: monthly builder vs buying once
Monthly store builders look cheap per month. Add five years of plan fees, apps and payment surcharges and the picture changes. Here's how to work out your own numbers, with a worked example. By the SaleCart team at Afriweb Internet · Updated 29 October 2026.
See the pricingWhy the five-year sum matters
A monthly store builder is easy to say yes to. The price is small, the sign-up takes five minutes and you never think about servers. But a shop isn't a five-minute project: most run for years.
So the useful question isn't "what does it cost this month?" but "what will it cost by the time the shop is five years old?" This guide walks through that sum honestly, with a worked example you can redo with your own numbers.
1. The four costs most people forget to add up
The plan price on the pricing page is only the first line. Over a few years, these add up too:
- The plan itself. Usually billed monthly, sometimes cheaper if you pay a year upfront. Plans also tend to go up over time, and the features you need (more staff accounts, better reports, lower card fees) are often on a higher plan.
- Apps and add-ons. Reviews, product options, wholesale prices, bookings, subscriptions, loyalty points, back-in-stock alerts and translations are often paid apps, each with its own monthly fee.
- Extra transaction fees. Some platforms add their own percentage on every sale if you don't use their in-house payment service, on top of what your card processor charges.
- Themes. A premium theme is usually a once-off cost, but switching later can mean buying another one.
None of these are hidden, exactly. They're just spread across different pages, and they arrive one at a time as the shop grows.
2. A worked example
Here's a simple small-shop example. The numbers are assumptions to show the method, not anyone's current price list: check today's prices for the platforms you're comparing and put your own figures in.
A monthly builder over five years
- Software: $39 a month × 60 months = $2,340
- Three paid apps (reviews, options, wishlist) at $10 a month each = $1,800
- Extra platform fee of 1% on $50,000 of sales = $500
- Hosting and domain: included
- Five-year total: $4,640
Buying SaleCart once
- Software: $99 once
- Reviews, options and wishlist: included
- Extra platform fee: none
- Hosting and domain: about $10 a month = $600
- Five-year total: $699
Card processing fees (Stripe, PayPal and so on) apply either way, so they're left out of both.
Change the numbers and the gap changes, but the shape usually stays the same: a monthly fee is small, and sixty of them aren't.
3. What "buy once" does and doesn't include
To compare fairly, you need to know what you're giving up as well as what you're saving. With SaleCart:
- You pay $99 once for a licence for one store. There's no monthly licence fee.
- You host it yourself. You need hosting that runs PHP 8.1 or newer with a MySQL or MariaDB database, which most ordinary web hosts offer. That's the "hosting and domain" line in the example.
- Six months of updates are included. Later versions and ongoing support aren't part of the $99. Your store keeps working on the version you have; you simply don't get newer versions automatically after six months.
- Custom work is quoted separately if you need a feature, a connection or a design change that isn't there.
So "buy once" isn't "free forever". It's paying for the software once, paying a normal web host for the place it runs, and deciding for yourself when (and whether) to pay for anything more.
Often paid apps elsewhere, included in SaleCart
4. When a monthly builder is the better choice
Buying once isn't right for everyone. A hosted builder may suit you better if:
- You're testing an idea for a few months and may not keep the shop.
- You don't want anything to do with hosting at all, not even choosing a host.
- You rely on a specific app or integration that only exists on one platform.
If you expect the shop to still be running in three or five years, though, it's worth doing the sum. For more on that trade-off, see self-hosted vs hosted ecommerce.
Your five-year checklist
Before you choose, write down:
- The plan you'd actually need in year two or three, not the cheapest one
- Every paid app you'd add, and its monthly price
- Any extra percentage the platform takes per sale, times your expected sales
- Hosting and domain costs, if you host yourself
- What happens to your store, products and customer list if you stop paying
That last one matters more than it looks. With a monthly platform, the shop stops when the payments stop. With software you've bought, the copy on your hosting is yours to keep running.
Want to see it working? Try a live demo store and open its admin demo, see how SaleCart compares and SaleCart vs Shopify, or read more online store guides.
Questions people ask
Is SaleCart really a once-off payment?
Yes: $99 once for a licence for one store, with no monthly licence fee. You pay your own web host for hosting and your domain. Six months of updates are included; later versions and ongoing support aren't.
What does hosting cost for a self-hosted store?
Ordinary shared hosting that runs PHP 8.1 or newer with a MySQL or MariaDB database is enough for most small stores. Prices vary by host and country, from a few dollars a month.
Do I still pay card fees with SaleCart?
Yes. Your payment provider, such as Stripe or PayPal, charges its own fee per payment, as it would on any platform. SaleCart adds no percentage of its own.
What happens after the six months of updates?
Your store keeps running on the version you have. You just don't get newer versions automatically. Custom work and add-ons are available on request with a quote first.
Can I move my products from a monthly platform?
Yes. SaleCart imports products, options, photos and categories from Shopify, WooCommerce, BigCommerce, Wix, Squarespace, Ecwid, Magento, PrestaShop, Etsy, Square, OpenCart and Zen Cart. See moving your store.

